
It has been years since a work of classical music generated the kind of attention that surrounded Missy Mazzoli’s new opera, Lincoln in the Bardo, during its premiere run at the Metropolitan Opera. Adapted from George Saunders’s Booker Prize-winning novel, the production’s opening was an institutional success. Critics praised it, tickets sold briskly and for several days afterward the Met streamed the closing performance on YouTube for free.
When I tuned in the day after the broadcast, the view count had already passed 184,000. For Mazzoli and her longtime librettist, Royce Vavrek, and for a Met administration eager to prove the vitality of contemporary opera, numbers like those are a triumph. But as I watched the stream, taking in the visual ambition of the staging and the power of Mazzoli’s score, a stubborn question surfaced for me. For all its popular success, did Lincoln in the Bardo actually succeed as an opera?
The opera’s shortcomings, as I saw them, had little to do with musical invention or theatrical imagination. They stemmed instead from dramatic focus. By trying to give voice to a broad community of ghosts, the opera spreads our attention too widely. Opera can sustain complexity, but it still depends on a handful of characters whose desires matter more than everyone else’s.
(more…)







